VSFTP与SFTP在CentOS区别

Protocol Foundation
VSFTP is a standalone FTP server daemon based on the FTP (File Transfer Protocol), which uses TCP port 21 for control connections and dynamically assigned ports (default: 20) for data transfer. SFTP, short for SSH File Transfer Protocol, is an integrated subsystem of SSH (Secure Shell)—it relies on the SSH protocol for all communication, using TCP port 22 exclusively for both control and data transmission.

Security Model
VSFTP’s default configuration lacks strong encryption, making it vulnerable to eavesdropping or man-in-the-middle attacks unless explicitly configured with SSL/TLS (via the ssl_enable directive in /etc/vsftpd/vsftpd.conf). Even with SSL/TLS, its security depends on proper certificate management. In contrast, SFTP provides end-to-end encryption by default—all data (including passwords) is encrypted during transfer. It supports multiple authentication methods (passwords, SSH keys) and integrates with the system’s SSH security policies (e.g., PasswordAuthentication in /etc/ssh/sshd_config).

Configuration Complexity
VSFTP requires manual editing of its primary configuration file (/etc/vsftpd/vsftpd.conf) to enable features like local user access (local_enable=YES), chroot restrictions (chroot_local_user=YES), or passive mode (pasv_enable=YES). The file includes many directives (e.g., anon_upload_enable, local_umask), making setup more complex for beginners. SFTP leverages the existing SSH service—no additional package installation is needed (beyond openssh-server). Configuration involves modifying just one directive in /etc/ssh/sshd_config (replacing Subsystem sftp /usr/libexec/openssh/sftp-server with Subsystem sftp internal-sftp) and optionally adding user-specific rules via Match blocks.

Performance Characteristics
VSFTP is generally faster than SFTP for large file transfers because it doesn’t incur the overhead of SSH encryption/decryption. This makes it suitable for scenarios where speed is critical (e.g., website file uploads, bulk data backups). SFTP’s performance is slightly lower due to encryption, but the difference is negligible for most everyday tasks. The trade-off is justified by SFTP’s superior security.

Port Usage & Firewall Requirements
VSFTP requires opening two ports (21 for control, 20 for active mode data) and configuring passive mode ports (a range of high ports) in the firewall and VSFTP config (via pasv_min_port/pasv_max_port). This complexity can lead to issues with restrictive firewalls. SFTP only needs port 22 open, simplifying firewall configuration and reducing exposure to unauthorized access.

Authentication & Access Control
VSFTP supports local system users, virtual users (via password files like /etc/vsftpd/ftpuserdb), and anonymous logins (though anonymous access is often disabled for security). Access control is managed through directives like chroot_local_user (restricts users to their home directories) and chroot_list_file (lists users exempt from chroot). SFTP relies on SSH users (local or LDAP) and integrates with PAM (Pluggable Authentication Modules) for authentication. Access control is more granular—users can be restricted to specific commands or directories via Match blocks in /etc/ssh/sshd_config (e.g., ChrootDirectory /var/ftp limits a user to the /var/ftp directory).

Use Case Suitability
VSFTP is ideal for environments needing traditional FTP functionality (e.g., compatibility with legacy clients, simple file sharing) where speed is a priority and additional security measures (like SSL/TLS) are implemented. SFTP is better suited for high-security scenarios (e.g., sensitive data transfer, remote server management) where encryption and integration with SSH are mandatory.

声明：本文内容由网友自发贡献，本站不承担相应法律责任。对本内容有异议或投诉，请联系2913721942#qq.com核实处理，我们将尽快回复您，谢谢合作！